AIBC

Architectural Institute of British Columbia

  • Professional Governance Act Transition
  • Find an Architect,Associate or Firm
  • RegistrantLogin
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • About
    • Organization
    • Regulatory Authority
    • Governance
    • Professional Governance Act Transition
    • Boards & Committees
    • Annual Meeting
    • Initiatives
    • Opportunities
    • Staff
    • Contact Us
    • Close
  • Registration
    • Become an Architect AIBC
    • Architects
    • Intern Architects
    • Architectural Technologists
    • Retired Architects
    • Architectural Firms
    • Temporary Licences
    • Honorary Members
    • Professional Mobility
    • Annual Renewal
    • Close
  • Programs & Services
    • Practice Advice
    • RFPs & Competitions
    • Contracts
    • Certified Professional Program
    • Post-Disaster Building Assessment
    • AIBC Classifieds
    • Municipal Matrix
    • Close
  • Professional Development
    • Continuing Education System (CES)
    • AIBC Courses & Professional Development
    • Recognized Educational Provider Program
    • Close
  • Protecting the Public
    • AIBC’s Regulatory Role
    • Does Your Project Need An Architect?
    • Complaints
    • Professional Conduct
    • Illegal Practice
    • Close
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
    • Architectural Walking Tours
    • Media
    • AIBC 100
    • Close
  • Resources
    • AIBC Resources
    • Industry Resources
    • Chapters
    • Affiliates
    • Online Directory
    • Close
Home / News / AIBC Happenings / Legal Ruling Announced on Municipal Permitting Decision in Favour of AIBC

Legal Ruling Announced on Municipal Permitting Decision in Favour of AIBC

June 3, 2020

In June 2019, the AIBC initiated legal action against the City of Langford arising out of an illegal practice matter – a decision by the City’s Chief Building Inspector to issue a building permit, without an architect engaged, for a residential/commercial building that required an architect under the Architects Act. The AIBC brought a ‘judicial review’ and sought a declaration from the BC Supreme Court that the local government must consider the Architects Act in its permitting decisions, and that failure to do so was unreasonable.

On May 29, 2020, the judgment in the City of Langford judicial review was released, and the AIBC was successful in having the declaration issued by the courts. The full decision can be read here.

Overview

As a public interest regulator, the AIBC’s position has been that the Architects Act is a public health and safety law that must be appropriately considered by local governments. Some authorities have taken the stance that as long as the BC Building Code is complied with, there is no additional duty to ‘enforce’ or consider the Architects Act. The Langford judicial review was an opportunity to clarify the legal strength of these positions, and, as stated by Mr. Justice Stephen Kelleher in the decision, the AIBC had clear “public interest standing” to bring the case to court.

Several highlights from the decision are summarized below:

  • The Architects Act is clearly a law relating to “health and safety”, with architects’ involvement in projects designed to minimize public risk through their specialized training, regulation by the AIBC, insurance coverage and continuing education [paragraphs 88-92];
  • In order for a decision-maker’s decision to be reasonable, all relevant factors must be taken into account, and the requirements of the Architects Act were not considered by the local government in this case [paragraphs 106-107];
  • The Building Code is a regulation under the Building Act, and cannot take precedence over the Architects Act (in terms of a local government deciding which ‘laws’ to follow or consider) [paragraphs 110-112];
  • Langford’s decision to issue the permit without considering the Architects Act was unreasonable, and “Intervention by this court is required to safeguard legality and rationality” [paragraphs 114-115]; and
  • The remedy of a “declaration” was appropriate to “provide guidance to municipal officials exercising their permitting powers.” [paragraphs 116-120].

This decision from the BC Supreme Court is a positive outcome that provides much-needed clarity regarding the intersection of the Architects Act and the municipal building permitting process in British Columbia. The case was advanced by the AIBC as a matter of public interest. The judicial confirmation of the status of the Architects Act is of benefit to building officials, owners, local governments across the province, and ultimately, the public.

While the AIBC was successful in this litigation, we will continue to work with local governments to achieve compliance through education and discussion, as ‘partners in the public interest’.

The AIBC is committed to providing guidance to the public, architects and other professionals, and local governments about the public protection role of the Institute through its mandate under the Architects Act. We encourage anybody with a professional practice question to contact one of our Practice Advisors at practiceadvice@aibc.ca. Any questions related to the Langford judgment can be directed to Thomas Lutes at tlutes@aibc.ca.

Resources

  • Architectural Institute of British Columbia v. Langford (City) 2020 BCSC 801 (CanLII) – legal decision
  •  Bulletin 31: Buildings Requiring the Services of an Architect
  • Does Your Project Need an Architect?

Filed Under: AIBC Happenings

« Previous Post
Next Post »
  • News & Events
    • News
      • AIBC Happenings
      • Industry News
      • eNewsletter Archives
    • Calendar
    • Signature Events & Programs
      • Induction & Retirement Ceremony
      • Conference and PD Day
      • Architectural Awards
        • architectureBC
      • Recognition Program
        • AIBC Lifetime Achievement Award
        • AIBC Special Recognition Award
        • The Barbara Dalrymple Memorial Award for Community Service
        • CEO Award for Exceptional Volunteer Service
        • AIBC Award for Lifetime Volunteer Achievement
        • Council Service Recognition
      • Architectural Walking Tours
        • Vancouver Architectural Walking Tours
        • Victoria Architectural Walking Tours
      • Architecture Centre Gallery
        • Current Exhibit
        • Past Exhibits
      • Scholarship & Bursary Program
    • Media
    • AIBC 100
    • AIBC Response to COVID-19

Main Pages

  • Home
  • About
  • Registration
  • Programs & Services
  • Professional Development
  • Protecting the Public
  • News & Events
  • Resources

Contact Us

Architectural Institute of B.C.
100 – 440 Cambie Street
Vancouver, British Columbia
Canada V6B 2N5
Tel: 604.683.8588 or toll free in BC 1.800.667.0753
Fax: 604.683.8568 or toll free in BC 1.800.661.2955
Email: reception@aibc.ca

Follow us

Quick Links

  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2023 AIBC